
|
Can a Trust be Contested?
Many people have heard of filing a Will Contest, or
Will Caveat, but many people are not aware that Trusts may also be
contested, modified, or terminated. Every Trust case is different and depends
upon the Trust instrument and the parties involved. If you believe you may have
a claim involving a Trust, you should consult with an attorney. Travis Morton is
an experienced Wills and Trusts litigator who can advise you of your rights and
possible claims you may have. You can email him at
travis@travismorton.com or call him at (919) 782-3500. Please remember that
the following information is for educational purposes and should not be relied
upon as legal advice.
Who are the Parties to a Trust?
A Trust is a written instrument giving directions on how Trust property should be held and eventually distributed. A Trust, unlike a Will, is a private document and may be shared only with those persons named in the Trust. For privacy reasons, may people may choose to distribute their property under a Trust rather than a publicly filed Will.
The Grantor gives legal title to the trust property to the
person known as the Trustee. In most Revocable Trusts, also known as Living
Trusts, the Grantor also serves as Trustee as long as he or she is capable of
serving. A Trust will name people who are to receive the property or income from
the property; these people are the Trust Beneficiaries. The Beneficiaries hold
what is known as equitable title to the Trust property. The Trustee, by holding
legal title, has the duty to manage and protect the Trust property for the
ultimate benefit of the Beneficiaries.
For example, John Smith executes a Trust agreement and
funds it with ten thousand dollars ($10,000.00). John Smith is the Grantor of
that Trust agreement. John Smith names himself as Trustee for as long as he is
capable of serving. John Smith’s Trust agreement names his two minor children as
the beneficiaries of the Trust who will each receive one-half of the Trust
property when the youngest child turns twenty-one years old. John Smith,
Grantor, has granted legal title to himself as Trustee and granted equitable, or
beneficial, title to his children as Beneficiaries.
Can Beneficiaries ask to modify the terms of or terminate a Trust?
Beneficiaries may disagree with the terms of the Trust
itself. The Uniform Trust Code (“UTC”) allows beneficiaries, under certain
circumstances, to petition for modification or termination of a Trust agreement.
A Trust, like a Will, can be contested and declared void if
the Grantor created the Trust due to fraud, duress, or undue influence.
A Trust, though validly created, may still be modified or
terminated by Court order. Terms within a Trust may be modified to correct
unintentional mistakes of the Grantor. Beneficiaries may petition to clarify
ambiguities in a Trust agreement. The Trustee of a small Trust (less than
$50,000.00 worth of cash or property) may petition the court to terminate the
Trust and allow for disbursement of funds to the named beneficiaries.
If you are the beneficiary of a Trust and believe you may
have a reason to petition for modification or termination of a Trust agreement,
an experienced attorney should be consulted so that they can review the terms of
the Trust. Travis Morton is an experienced Wills and Trusts litigator who can
advise you of your rights and possible claims you may have. You can email him at
travis@travismorton.com or call him
at (919) 782-3500.
What are the duties of a person serving as Trustee?
A person serving as Trustee is charged with the management
and care of Trust property until such time as the Trust agreement allows the
Trustee to give the property to the Beneficiaries. A Trustee cannot use the
money or property in a Trust for his or her own benefit.
North Carolina, along with many other states, have adopted
the Uniform Trust Code and the Uniform Prudent Investor Act which provide
guiding principals enforceable at law as to the proper behavior and duties of
persons serving as Trustee.
The UTC provides that a person serving as Trustee must, at all times, act in
good faith, act in loyalty to the Trust agreement and beneficiaries, and be
impartial in its treatment of beneficiaries named in the Trust. A Trustee must
also, upon request of a qualified beneficiary, provide, “complete and accurate
information as to the nature and amount of the trust property and to permit the
beneficiary, or the beneficiary's representative, to inspect the subject matter
of the trust and the accounts and other documents relating to the trust.” Please
note that only the qualified beneficiaries of a Trust are able to request such
information from the Trustee. Furthermore, the UTC provides different standards
for Trustees, depending upon the relative skill of the Trustee. An individual
family member without formal financial or legal skills may be held to a
different standard when serving as Trustee than the standard to which the law
holds a corporate Trust company serving as Trustee.
The Uniform Prudent Investor Act (“UPIA”) provides further
guidance to a Trustee as to how Trust property should be managed and invested.
Most simply, UPIA requires the Trustee to, “invest and manage trust assets as a
prudent investor would, by considering the purposes, terms, distribution
requirements, and other circumstances of the trust.” The Prudent Investor Rule
requires the Trustee to consider circumstances in addition to the terms of the
Trust, such as general economic conditions, inflation or deflation,
diversification, and the possible tax consequences of particular management or
investment strategies. Individuals serving as Trustees are allowed to hire
financial and legal professionals to help them properly serve as Trustee under
the UPIA.
What if a Trustee is not properly performing the duties of a Trustee?
Beneficiaries of a Trust, like beneficiaries of a Will or
intestate estate, have the right, or legal standing, to sue to enforce the terms
of the Trust or the duties of the Trustee. Beneficiaries must show that the
Trustee has breached his or her duties in order to be granted relief by the
Court. Relief may include ordering a Trustee to produce accountings to the
Beneficiaries, compelling a Trustee to prudently invest trust property, or
removing the Trustee and appointing a successor Trustee. A Trustee generally
cannot be sued for serving in reliance upon the terms of the Trust agreement.
If you are the beneficiary of a Trust and strongly disagree
with how the Trustee is managing trust property, an experienced attorney should
be consulted so that they can review the terms of the Trust. Travis Morton is an
experienced Wills and Trusts litigator who can advise you of your rights and
possible claims you may have. You can email him at
travis@travismorton.com or call him
at (919) 782-3500.
|